I just watched "Melinda and Melinda" on HBO On Demand and loved it. I was surprised to see the poor reviews of it on rottentomatoes.com. The tomatometer it at around 50%.
The movie opens with two playwrights and their friends at a Manhattan restaurant discussing whether the essence of life is comic or tragic.
One of the friends at the table says, "Look, let me tell you a story and you tell me, is it material for a comedy or a tragedy?"
The friend begins to tell a story about a woman named Melinda who barges in on a dinner party one night.
The comedy writer says the story has the makings of a good romantic comedy, but the other playwright sees tragic implications and begins to tell the story from his point of view.
The story comes to life with Rhada Mitchell playing Melinda, the uninvited guest. She's lost custody of her kids in a bitter divorce and has come to stay with her friend, the hostess of the dinner party.
The comedic writer interrupts the story, then retells it after shuffling the characters and the details around. Mitchell also plays Melinda in the comedic version of the story, but against a different cast if characters.
The rest of the film moves back and forth between the two stories and commentary by the playwrights and their friends.
When I watched the movie, I was deconstructing it (no Woody pun intended) the entire time which is what made it fun -- trying to figure out which were the parallel characters and looking for the details that linked the two stories.
But, what I liked about the film, critic Andrew Sarris called a "conceptual disaster on Mr. Allen's part." Jonathan Rosenbaum in the Chicago Reader wrote, "I couldn't buy that two supposedly sophisticated theater people could be so simplemenided about what defines comedy and tragedy. I also couldn't belive in most of the characters including either version of Melinda."
The movie's tag line sums up its point: "Life can be a comedy or a tragedy, it all depends on how you look at it."
The message is similar to Mickey's (Woody Allen) at the end of "Hannah and Her Sisters."
What if there's no God, and you
only go around once and that's it?
Well, you know, don't you want to
be part of the experience? You
know, what the hell, it-i-it's not
all a drag. And I'm thinking to
myself, geez, I should stop ruining
my life...
Although I believe there is a God, I like the sentiment of that speech because it points out how very often we're the source of our own distress, especially when we let our inner kvetch machine get the better of us. (I did way too much of that this week and it didn't help me feel any better!)
So, quit agonizing and start seeing the humor in things. (Go see "Scoop," Woody's latest!)
Recent Comments